Beyond the Rates: Proprietary Payer Reimbursement Methodologies
Part 3 of Beyond the Rates: The Contract Terms That Shape Reimbursement

When a payer tacks its name onto a reimbursement methodology, do you really know what you’ll get paid?
Consider a health system whose contract reimburses inpatient services under a diagnosis-related group (DRG) methodology. Its contracted DRG base rate for commercial products is 200% of its CMS DRG base rate (under Medicare IPPS), so the health system expects inpatient reimbursement to be equivalent to 200% of what traditional Medicare would reimburse*. At that level, the health system expects $32,000 for the inpatient stay, but receives only $25,000, nearly 22% less than anticipated. By year’s end, the health system has received $39.1 million in cumulative inpatient reimbursement rather than the budgeted $50 million.
In this hypothetical, the health system’s contract uses a DRG methodology; however, it is not CMS’s MS-DRG methodology. The payer uses proprietary relative weights that are significantly lower than CMS’s weights for the corresponding DRGs. Looking back at its contract, the health system confirms that the payment appendix specifies “[Payer Name] DRG methodology.” Simply by including its own name in front, the payer had communicated that an otherwise well-understood reimbursement methodology was its own proprietary methodology; only one or two words in the contract conveyed the difference.
* For simplicity, the above example omits CMS IPPS adjustments such as IME, DSH, etc. and focuses on the foundational MS-DRG elements - the base rate and relative weights.
Contract Language Matters
Contract language can support the predictability and magnitude of reimbursement or undermine it materially. Even when reimbursement methodologies and rates appear to be clearly specified, revenue may remain uncertain. Reimbursement is only as reliable as the other provisions supporting it, or, in this case, the small qualifiers that change a standard methodology into a proprietary payer methodology.
This multipart series focuses on commercial payer contracts and identifies contract details with the potential to materially impact revenue. Part 1 focused on when payments become final and how long payers and providers have to correct errors, and Part 2 focused on overpayment collections occurring through payment offsets. This third installment examines proprietary payer reimbursement methodologies—payment methodologies that may incorporate components of industry standards but follow payer-defined rules.
The central questions are: Does the reimbursement methodology follow a referenced standard? If not, what are the rules? Are they subject to change?
A Familiar Sounding Reimbursement Methodology may be Misleading
If the name seems familiar, we may automatically associate it with a known methodology, even if it shouldn’t be. A shake isn’t a milkshake. Krab isn’t crab. Whipped topping isn’t whipped cream. The same may be true of reimbursement methodologies in payer-provider contracts. “[Payer Name] DRG” methodology does not necessarily mean CMS’s MS-DRG or a state Medicaid program’s APR-DRG methodology. A methodology labeled “[Payer Name] DRG” may use different weights, payment rules, or adjustments than the CMS or state methodology the health system expects. The familiar name creates a false sense of certainty, even though the underlying methodology may differ and materially alter reimbursement.
What Are the Potential Issues with Proprietary Payer Reimbursement Methodologies?
Industry-standard methodologies have their own pros and cons; however, proprietary payer reimbursement methodologies can introduce additional risks that should be understood.
The payer:
may not share details about how the methodology works, making it difficult for the health system to project near-term or long-term reimbursement levels.
may have unfettered decision-making authority and control over elements of the reimbursement methodology and the right to make changes at any time.
may not be obligated to notify the health system when it makes changes to the methodology or reimbursement levels.
Are Proprietary Reimbursement Methodologies Always an Issue?
There may be legitimate reasons for a payer to use a proprietary reimbursement methodology. Proprietary methodologies have the potential to:
prevent unanticipated CMS-driven or state-driven reimbursement level changes or increase the predictability of reimbursement for both parties.
improve claims processing by better aligning with the payer’s claims platform limitations.
reduce administrative burden for both parties.
While benefits are possible, the proprietary methodology may give the payer disproportionate control. When a contract follows an external methodology such as CMS’s or a state’s, neither contracting party independently controls changes to that methodology. If the payer instead has sole authority to determine changes, will the balance between the parties’ interests be preserved?
The positive potential isn’t enough, and risks should be managed. Before agreeing to a proprietary reimbursement methodology, information, obligations, and rights must be disclosed and agreed upon to ensure that the arrangement works fairly and predictably for both parties.
What Protections Are Recommended When Considering a Proprietary Methodology?
In order for a proprietary reimbursement methodology to be sustainable, all elements needed to calculate reimbursement must be disclosed, permissible changes must be defined and limited, and the health system must be protected against adverse financial impacts.
Transparency
Does my contract say exactly what I will be paid, or do I have to go to the payer’s website to figure it out? Even more concerning, do I have to submit a request to the payer to receive this information?
One of the most important elements when considering a proprietary reimbursement methodology is transparency. The health system should have enough information to model reimbursement under the proposed methodology and understand how future changes will be determined. An inability to evaluate the financial terms should be a deal-breaking concern.
Reimbursement Predictability
In addition to fully defining all aspects necessary to determine reimbursement, health systems need to know which components are subject to change. Will they be told in advance, and if so, with how much notice? Can reimbursement be reduced? Can the methodology or its underlying elements be changed?
Allow Routine Coding Updates with Proper Rules - The payer will typically need the ability to make routine maintenance updates. For example, the payer will need to implement coding changes, additions or deletions. The scope of permitted changes and how they will be implemented should be defined. Updates should preserve negotiated reimbursement for equivalent services, and payment for new codes should follow explicitly defined criteria.
Require a Written Amendment for Other Changes - Other than routine coding updates expressly permitted by the contract, changes should require a written amendment signed by both parties. Without that agreement, the payer should not be permitted to reduce reimbursement or otherwise alter how it is determined. While this is the ideal outcome, market dynamics, payer-provider circumstances, or other factors may limit a health system’s ability to secure this protection.
Seek to Be Made Whole for Adverse Financial Impacts - If a signed amendment is not required prior to implementing a change, the health system could consider negotiating “make-whole language.” If agreed upon, this would require the payer to reimburse the health system for any unfavorable financial impact or increased administrative burden due to a change in the reimbursement methodology.
A make-whole provision should specify how losses will be calculated, when and how payment will be made, how disagreements will be resolved, and the steps required to obtain payment. Without clearly documented steps, a process gap can undermine the value of the provision, and the health system may struggle to recover its losses.
Negotiate an Expedited Termination Right - An expedited termination right may be easier to negotiate than other protections and could limit the duration of a health system’s exposure to unfavorable changes. For example, if the health system, in its sole discretion, believes that there is an unfavorable financial impact or an increased administrative burden due to the change, it could have the right to terminate in a substantially shorter timeframe than the contract generally requires.
Contractual Protection
Contrary to what you might expect, some payers do not specify any reimbursement information whatsoever in certain provider agreements. In these instances, the contract does not specify the level of payment - no sample reimbursement, no basis for the fee schedule structure, no commitment to a reimbursement level today or in the future, and often, no payer obligations for communicating changes. Why establish a payer relationship on such uneven financial footing? Provider contracts need specific, legally binding documentation of reimbursement.
Medical Groups and Ancillary Providers
For medical groups and ancillary providers, the agreement may simply state that the provider will be paid according to the “[Payer Name] Fee Schedule, which may change from time to time.” This approach may be used by statewide, regional, and sometimes even national payers. How would the medical group or ancillary provider forecast revenue, know if a claim has been paid correctly, or plan for the next fiscal year?
Regardless of provider type, the contract should include the full fee schedule or a complete, reproducible method for calculating reimbursement. If payment is based on Medicare, identify the CMS RBRVS methodology, year, geographic basis, and negotiated percentage. Simply referencing a fee schedule posted on the payer website or stating that the fee schedule is available upon request would be problematic. Similarly, a sample of reimbursement amounts included in the contract is not a comprehensive solution.
Hospitals
The omission of detailed reimbursement information isn’t solely a medical group or ancillary provider concern; some payers use this simple proprietary fee schedule approach for certain hospital services. For example, the hospital’s outpatient radiological services or laboratory services may be paid according to the [Payer Name] Radiology Fee Schedule or [Payer Name] Lab Fee Schedule without specifying the reimbursement basis or amounts.
In other instances, the payer’s proprietary hospital reimbursement methodology may be far more complex and harder to spot, as the opening [Payer Name] DRG Methodology example illustrates. Assessment of these methodologies should be comprehensive. A favorable base rate does not ensure favorable reimbursement if other payment components are payer-defined or subject to change. Health systems need complete information specifying how reimbursement is calculated to determine what they will be paid.
If the parties seek to base inpatient reimbursement on a DRG methodology, why not reference the current CMS inpatient prospective payment system (IPPS) methodology and specify how to apply subsequent CMS updates?
Consider Negotiating Exceptions: Replicating CMS IPPS exactly may not make sense - consider case rates for NICU and maternity services, outlier or stop-loss provisions when billed charges exceed a certain threshold, high-cost drug and implant carveouts, non-CMS reimbursement methodologies for children’s hospitals, etc.
Does an Obligation to Comply with State Law Always Provide Protection?
Some external protections exist, but their applicability and scope vary significantly by state, plan type, and contract arrangement, and they may not prevent reimbursement reductions. Also, as discussed in Parts 1 and 2 of this series, protections may apply to fully insured coverage but may not extend to self-funded ERISA plans.
Depending on the state, protections may include:
A payer obligation to disclose the fee schedule or payment methodology, although it may be limited to certain circumstances or only provide partial information.
Restrictions on how payers change reimbursement. They may be required to:
Provide advance notice of reimbursement changes.
Comply with restrictions on retroactive reimbursement revisions.
Offer a right to negotiate, object, or terminate in response to reimbursement changes.
These safeguards may not provide all needed protections. Some potential limitations include:
Limited transparency:
Payers may only be required to provide reimbursement information when requested.
Payers may not be required to include reimbursement detail in the contract itself.
The statutorily required reimbursement information may be insufficient to fully model reimbursement.
No restrictions on use of proprietary methodologies.
An obligation to provide notice and an option to terminate in advance, but payers may retain the right to reduce reimbursement.
Protections and Limitations by State
The following examples illustrate differences in state protections and their limitations.
State | Relevant Protection | Important Limitation |
|---|---|---|
Texas[1] | Insurance Code §1301.136 requires applicable preferred-provider contracts to:
| Does not require use of Medicare methodology or prohibit reimbursement reductions. |
Kentucky[2] | Under KRS §304.17A-577, managed-care insurers are required to provide, upon request, sufficient information to determine payment prior to contract execution or renewal. Generally, fee-schedule changes must be available 90 days before taking effect. | Disclosure may occur electronically or through a website. |
California[3] | Under §1375.7(b)(1)(A), covered plans generally must negotiate and obtain provider agreement before changing a material contract term and provide at least 45 business days’ notice. | Unilateral material changes may be permitted for preferred-provider arrangements if notice and a right to terminate are provided prior to implementation. |
North Carolina[4] | G.S. §58-3-227 generally requires at least 30 days’ advance notice prior to fee schedule and reimbursement policy changes. | Notice is the main protection. The payer is not required to secure a provider’s agreement prior to making a change. |
Given the gaps and limitations, defaulting to statutory protections is not enough. Health systems need explicit contractual protections for components not addressed in state law and for plans outside the statutes’ purview.
Contract Review: Where the Details Matter
A minor difference in wording can dramatically affect meaning and financial impact. To ensure proper protection, provisions should specify the steps in the process and each party’s rights and obligations. Vague or incomplete language may fail to provide certainty and adequate protection.
Permitted Reimbursement Changes and Their Timing: Does the contract language allow code-level or more holistic methodology changes in all circumstances or only certain, specified instances? Are changes permitted annually, quarterly, or at any time? Are they only permitted prospectively, or are they also allowed retroactively? How quickly must changes be implemented? If changes apply retroactively, will previously paid claims be reprocessed?
Is Notice Required: Notice of a change in reimbursement amount or methodology may be entirely at the payer’s discretion. Even if required, the obligation to notify may be limited to certain circumstances.
Notice Period: Does the contract specify a minimum notice period before a change may be implemented? Does it also provide time for the provider to object? Without a minimum notice period, changes may be permitted immediately upon provision of notice.
Advance Notice May Not Prevent Retroactive Reductions: A payer may be required to provide 45 days’ notice prior to implementing a change, but the language may still allow the change to be effective retroactively.
Information in the Notice: Must the payer identify the affected services, codes, rates, or methodology components; explain the changes; and specify the effective date? Will the health system receive sufficient detail to evaluate the financial impact before implementation?
Method of Notice: What method of delivery fulfills the notice obligation? If the contract permits electronic notice through email, a payer’s portal, or its newsletter, is the information likely to get to the right person? Requiring notice via certified mail, return receipt requested, increases reliability and provability of delivery. If no delivery method is specified, the manner of delivery may be entirely at the payer’s discretion.
Recipient of Notice: Must written notice be provided to a specific department, individual(s) with a particular title, or a named person? Without a clearly defined recipient who will continue to be relevant over time, notice may be misrouted or lost.
The objective is to make reimbursement clear and predictable rather than leaving current or future reimbursement unknown or entirely within the payer’s control.
Develop Insights and Take Action
Don’t wait for $50 million to turn into $39.1 million. Make sure you know the detail behind your contract’s reimbursement methodology. Financial predictability requires more than negotiated rates. It requires clearly defined payment methodology and enforceable protections that both parties have agreed upon.
BDC Advisors helps health systems evaluate contract language and model existing and proposed reimbursement. We identify risks and translate findings into negotiation strategies. We lead managed care contract negotiations, work alongside internal teams, or advise behind the scenes, from initial assessment through agreement completion.
To assess whether your contract language affects reimbursement and develop a strategy to address the risks, contact Carrie Knowles-Atkinson, Principal, at carrie.knowles-atkinson@bdcadvisors.com.
Coming in Part 4: Administrative Denials and the Importance of Medical Necessity Protections
Sources
[1] Texas Insurance Code §1301.136, Availability of Coding Guidelines.
[2] Kentucky Revised Statutes §304.17A-577, Disclosure of Payment or Fee Schedule.
[3] California Health and Safety Code §1375.7, Health Care Providers’ Bill of Rights.
[4] North Carolina General Statutes §58-3-227, Health Plans Fee Schedules.
About BDC Advisors
BDC Advisors was founded to lead constructive change in healthcare financing and delivery. We are a healthcare consulting firm that exclusively serves health systems, academic medical centers, and health plans to achieve sustainable growth and market share gains, increase revenues, improve margins, and deliver 10x-30x ROI or more in year one. Since 1990, we have advised two-thirds of the top 50 U.S. health systems, eight of the top ten academic medical centers, and five of the six largest U.S. health plans. Our senior experts work directly with executive leadership teams to anticipate change, solve complex problems, and turn strategic priorities into innovative and measurable action. In 2026, Healthcare Business Outlook recognized BDC as a Top 10 Healthcare Consulting Service Provider.
BDC Advisors serves clients across five core practice areas: Health Enterprise Strategy; Payer-Provider Strategy & Performance; Physician Enterprise Transformation; Mergers, Acquisitions, & Partnerships; and Population Health Management.



Comments